Catch 22? Wisconsin Supreme Court on Contributing to the Delinquency of a 17 year-old

by Kids Forward | November 20, 2010

Home 9 Youth Justice 9 Catch 22? Wisconsin Supreme Court on Contributing to the Delinquency of a 17 year-old ( Page 20 )

In a decision released this week, the Wisconsin Supreme Court held that a defendant, who provided a 17-year-old girl with Oxycodone, causing her death, was rightfully convicted of first-degree reckless homicide by delivery of a controlled substance and contributing to the delinquency of a child. The defendant argued that it was legally impossible to contribute to the delinquency of a 17-year-old. Why? Because in Wisconsin, for the purposes of investigation and prosecution, a 17-year-old is considered an adult. The court, however, rejected the defendant’s argument and held that the 17-year-old victim was a child in this context. The court further opined that proscribing the act of contributing to the delinquency of a child is “meant to protect children from those who would encourage them to become delinquent…[and] to protect children from harm by shielding them from the dangers of breaking the law.” 

In responding to the Court’s decision, Attorney General Hollen said, “[d]rug abuse often leads to tragic consequences, especially for younger users…I’m gratified that our supreme court held [the defendant] fully accountable” for the death of 17-year old Tanya S.. This does not address the question of how, on the one hand 17-year olds are considered adults yet in this context, the victim “was a child”. Things that make you go hmmmmm?

Interested in working to ensure that all 17-year olds are treated as children in the State of Wisconsin? Join the WCCF by signing our Justice for Wisconsin Youth Statement of Agreement available on our website: https://kidsforward.org/justice_statement.php.

Join us to build a Wisconsin where every child and family thrives.

Recent

Early Care & Education: Supporting Wisconsin Families During Children’s Early Years

Early Care & Education: Supporting Wisconsin Families During Children’s Early Years

Regardless of race, place, or income, every child in Wisconsin deserves a strong start in life. This early foundation plays a critical role in life-long health and wellness. But systemic racism and poverty destabilizes families and communities and creates unhealthy conditions and barriers that harm children in their early development. This process of destabilization not only prevents children from having a strong start but can persist over the course of their lives.

Mental Health: A Behavioral Health System that Better Supports Counties and Schools

Mental Health: A Behavioral Health System that Better Supports Counties and Schools

Everyone in Wisconsin, regardless of what county they live in, deserves to live in a community that supports their health and wellness, including access to quality, affordable mental health and substance use disorder services. Governor Evers’ proposed budget expands access to behavioral health care, strengthens schools’ abilities to provide mental health supports to students, invests in peer support, and provides millions in funding to county behavioral health services.

Sign up for Emails

Your address helps us identify your legislators and the most relevant messages to send you.