Juvenile Life without Parole takes Center Stage at the Supreme Court Today

by Kids Forward | March 20, 2012

Home 9 Youth Justice 9 Juvenile Life without Parole takes Center Stage at the Supreme Court Today ( Page 2 )

Today the Supreme Court heard arguments that could push our nation further along the road of justice for juveniles. You can get a recap of the arguments and what transpired today through the SCOTUS blog.  The Court has been on that road for several years already, having made two landmark decisions benefiting convicted kids. In 2005 they abolished the death penalty for children. In 2010, they abolished life sentences without parole for non-homicidal crimes committed by minors. Clearly the Court gives credence to scientific evidence that psychologically, emotionally and biologically, adolescents’ behaviors cannot be predicted or evaluated as adults’ can be.

The two cases heard today both involve crimes committed when the offenders were only fourteen years old. In one the person did not cause the murder, but was present during the crime. These cases will allow the Court to consider two important issues: First, whether life without parole should be allowed in sentencing juveniles, particularly younger teens; second, whether life without parole should be allowed for juveniles convicted of homicidal crimes, but who were themselves not the killer. Although forty-three states currently allow life without parole sentences for minors, only eighteen states impose them.

As Kristin Henning writes, “The same immaturity and flexibility that makes juveniles more susceptible to peer influences … also makes them quite resilient and capable of remarkable change.” Today’s cases will allow the Court to weigh in once again on the role developmental factors should play in sentencing. They will be able to further define those situations where kids, simply because of their developmental circumstances, should be given a chance at reform. We won’t know until this summer how the court rules, but either way it is a step forward in the growing consensus that young offenders, especially very young offenders, are not adults and should not be treated as adults!   By Tricia Egan

Join us to build a Wisconsin where
every child and family thrives.

Recent

State Budget: Youth Justice

State Budget: Youth Justice

Tough-on-Crime Narratives Uphold Wasteful Spending and a Developmentally Inappropriate Juvenile Justice System Main Takeaways Wisconsin relies far too much on incarceration and blames children for system-wide disinvestment in basic needs. Protecting our children means...

State Budget: Health Care

State Budget: Health Care

Governor’s Proposed Budget Expands Access to Health Care and Helps Reduce Racial Disparities Main Takeaways No matter where we live or what we look like, we all deserve to live safe and healthy lives. We all need access to quality, affordable health care that supports...

Fact Sheet: Every Healthy Baby Starts with Healthy Parents

Fact Sheet: Every Healthy Baby Starts with Healthy Parents

The below fact sheet was developed by Kids Forward with the Wisconsin Chapter of the American Academy of Pediatrics.  Download as PDF Providing postpartum Medicaid coverage for 12 months will help ensure both parents and babies in Wisconsin thrive together....

Sign up for Emails

Your address helps us identify your legislators and the most relevant messages to send you.