The Supreme Court Rules in Favor of Ensuring Youthful Offenders Understand their Rights

by Kids Forward | June 16, 2011

Home 9 Youth Justice 9 The Supreme Court Rules in Favor of Ensuring Youthful Offenders Understand their Rights ( Page 20 )
In a US Supreme Court decision (J.D.B. v. North Carolina) released today, the Court ruled (5-4) that a youth’s age does need to be considered as a factor when giving Miranda warnings – particularly as it relates to a youth’s ability to understand whether or not they are “in custody” and can adequately exercise consent to be questioned. 

The case involved a 13-year-olds student in North Carolina who was questioned by police related to two home break-ins but was not given his Miranda warnings until after confessing.  That seems “backward” to say the least, but the decision revolves around the underlying issues of whether a youth really understands that they are “free to leave” when questioned by law enforcement – a critical factor in determining at what point in questioning/conversations by police actual warnings need to be given.

This case continues a trend toward reflecting an understanding that there are cognition and other developmental differences that need to be considered when applying “adult-like” procedures to youthful offenders and is a step in the right direction in preserving the rights of youth when dealing with much more sophisticated adults.

Join us to build a Wisconsin where every child and family thrives.

Recent

Early Care & Education: Supporting Wisconsin Families During Children’s Early Years

Early Care & Education: Supporting Wisconsin Families During Children’s Early Years

Regardless of race, place, or income, every child in Wisconsin deserves a strong start in life. This early foundation plays a critical role in life-long health and wellness. But systemic racism and poverty destabilizes families and communities and creates unhealthy conditions and barriers that harm children in their early development. This process of destabilization not only prevents children from having a strong start but can persist over the course of their lives.

Mental Health: A Behavioral Health System that Better Supports Counties and Schools

Mental Health: A Behavioral Health System that Better Supports Counties and Schools

Everyone in Wisconsin, regardless of what county they live in, deserves to live in a community that supports their health and wellness, including access to quality, affordable mental health and substance use disorder services. Governor Evers’ proposed budget expands access to behavioral health care, strengthens schools’ abilities to provide mental health supports to students, invests in peer support, and provides millions in funding to county behavioral health services.

Sign up for Emails

Your address helps us identify your legislators and the most relevant messages to send you.