Do Youth in Juvenile Court Really Need to be Shackled?

by Kids Forward | February 19, 2015

Home 9 Youth Justice 9 Do Youth in Juvenile Court Really Need to be Shackled?

It is common practice in Wisconsin and around the country that youth who are in secure custody come into their court hearings in shackles of one kind or another.  Almost always this is because that is how adult inmates are transported and attend hearings.  Security and safety reasons are most often cited by the agencies responsible for providing the transport and courtroom security, but the fact is that shackling is done routinely despite an absence of data that supports the need and despite growing concerns and evidence that the indiscriminate and unnecessary use of restraints is harmful to youth who already have a history of experiencing trauma and are struggling to figure out where they fit into our society.  (By the way, this is another reason why putting youth in secure custody who don’t really need to be there can actually increase the likelihood of bad outcomes).

A growing number of states are joining the Campaign against Indiscriminate Juvenile Shackling, developing statutes or court rules that presume such shackling is not needed for court appearances unless there is sufficient evidence to support safety/security concerns.  Wisconsin courts need to take a cue from the position of the American Bar Association that “flips” the presumption to a practice in which shackles are not used unless there is evidence such restraints are needed.

By Jim Moeser

Join us to build a Wisconsin where
every child and family thrives.

Recent

State Budget: Early Care & Education

State Budget: Early Care & Education

Main Takeaways Child care is unaffordable and unavailable for too many working families. Child care staff are severely underpaid and this critical industry is on the verge of collapse unless there is continued economic support. The Governor's budget takes several...

State Budget: Immigration

State Budget: Immigration

Main Takeaways Wisconsin is home to nearly 300,000 immigrants, and they are vital contributors to the economic and social fabric of our communities. Despite their significant contributions, immigrants face barriers in their daily lives. The Governor’s 2025-27 State...

The Room Where it Happens: Attend a State Budget Hearing

The Room Where it Happens: Attend a State Budget Hearing

In February, Governor Evers proposed his state budget. Read our reaction here and some of our analysis here (more to come soon!).  The Governor’s proposals now go to the Joint Committee on Finance (often called the Joint Finance Committee or JFC). This powerful...

Sign up for Emails

Your address helps us identify your legislators and the most relevant messages to send you.